Indian Idle

Life is probably the most unfair thing to live through sometimes. I certainly saw first hand what that means yesterday. The Indian Idol turned out to be nothing more than a farce and the winner was one who won not because of his talent, but because of where he hails from.

You would think that after 60 years of democracy, Indians would understand the concept of voting. You would think that most people who voted actually had 2 ears to listen to what and how the contestants were singing. Considering that the process spanned 7 and a half months, results should have been announced sooner. The finale by itself was a 3 hour drag at the end of which I was left with a bitter taste in my mouth.

It just goes to show that in India, you can't achieve too many things by voting. Many people are losing their faith in the voting process as it is. The only way this could have been fair for us was if we had let the experts decide who can win and who can't. Would Donald Trump hire somebody on Apprentice because he/she has got more votes than the other?

I don't think that Prashant should have been in the top two in the first place. There were 2-3 singers ahead of him - and they were quite a distance away from him in terms of quality. Emon, Deepali and Chang would have driven Amit Paul close but make no mistake; Amit Paul deserved to be Indian Idol by a zillion miles.

You can only determine a good singer on the basis of his/her voice.. not his memory or his/her ability to remember lyrics. A slip in lyrics means very less. I remember the lyrics of a lot of songs; does that make me a good singer? I invite you to come and listen to my voice and decide for yourself (if you're alive after such an experience!).

It is frustrating when there is injustice in this world. It is frustrating when Bollywood stars get bail for a stonewall jail term. It was hard enough to keep your eyes open after a 3 hour snooze fest and at the end of it I felt like throwing stones at my TV.

We've been a democracy for 60 years and considering that all our politicians turn out to be utter flops.. I cannot fault the Indian public for not bucking the trend. As for Amit Paul, he is the true Indian Idol. Prashant may be a good human being, but he should be counting his lucky stars – which means that he should count every single star in the universe.